By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Logic & LayersLogic & Layers
  • Tools
  • Earn with AI
  • Productivity
  • Automation
  • Guides
Logic & LayersLogic & Layers
  • Privacy Policy
  • About
Search
  • Tools
  • Earn with AI
  • Productivity
  • Automation
  • Guides
  • About
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Privacy Policy
  • Complaint
  • Advertise
© 2026 Logic and Layers. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Paul Bakker, the software engineer who wrote the essay Don't use AI to write
Productivity

Stop using AI to write. Here’s what it costs you

Editorial Team
Last updated: September 21, 2026 2:28 pm
Editorial Team
Share
Software engineer Paul Bakker argues that writing forces the thinking that AI drafts skip.

Writers now use AI more than ever, and trust it less than ever. A recent survey of American writers found 71% use AI in their work, yet 60% distrust AI-supported writing, including their own. Both things can be true at once, and together they make a strong case for thinking twice before using AI to write your next draft.

Contents
The essay that hit a nerveWhat the numbers sayWriting is the thinkingWhere AI genuinely helps writersA workflow that keeps you in chargeThe honest tradeoff

The essay that hit a nerve

Software engineer Paul Bakker published a short essay in August called Don’t use AI to write, and it climbed to the front page of Hacker News within hours. His argument fits in one line: writing requires thinking, and letting a chatbot do the writing means letting it do the thinking too.

What makes the essay interesting is that Bakker isn’t an AI holdout. He uses Claude, ChatGPT and Gemini all day, for coding, research, and digging through data. His complaint is narrower. When you feed bullet points into a model and get a polished document out, you skip the part where ideas get forced into shape. The draft looks good. You accept it with small tweaks. And you never find out what you would have thought if you’d had to write it yourself.

That’s the trap. AI is genuinely good at writing, which is exactly why outsourcing to it feels harmless. The output is fluent, so nobody argues with it. But fluency isn’t the product. The product is the idea underneath, and the idea is what got skipped.

What the numbers say

The discomfort isn’t just one engineer’s opinion. A Harris Poll survey of 1,175 American writers, run for Medium in August 2026, put numbers on it. Seventy-one percent now use AI in some part of their writing. Yet 60% of respondents distrust AI-assisted writing even when they produced it themselves, and 69% distrust it when someone else did.

Read that again. Most writers don’t trust work they know they used AI on, work they presumably reviewed. That’s not technophobia. That’s people telling you the review didn’t make them confident.

Readers outside the writing world are catching on too. A public test by SEO research firm DEJAN found that people correctly identify AI-written answers 64% of the time, and their accuracy climbs the longer they read. A separate consumer survey by Fractl found the share of people who say heavy AI use in a brand’s content lowers their trust has nearly doubled in a year, from 20% to 39%. Sounding human isn’t a stylistic preference anymore. It’s becoming a trust requirement.

For anyone using AI to write anything that carries their name, the direction is clear. Usage keeps climbing, and so does the penalty for sounding generated.

Writing is the thinking

Here’s the core of Bakker’s case, and it deserves a fair hearing. Ask yourself what actually happens when you write something hard. You start with a vague sense of what you want to say. Then sentence by sentence, the vagueness collapses. Words refuse to fit. The argument has gaps you hadn’t noticed. Finding the right phrasing is how you find out your idea was half-formed.

Skip that process and you skip the discovery. A generated document can’t reveal what you think, because you didn’t think it. You’ll notice this the first time someone asks you a question about your own AI-written proposal and you can’t answer without rereading it.

It also explains why using AI to write leaves so many people vaguely unsatisfied with the result. The document exists, yet its author has no deeper grasp of the subject than before starting. Fluent output hides an absent process.

Productivity obsessed teams get this backwards, Bakker argues. Output volume measures nothing here. A three-page strategy document you actually thought through beats a sixty-page generated one that hedges every point, because only one of them contains a decision. Programming has the same trap, he points out: nobody counts lines of code as progress, but people count pages.

Where AI genuinely helps writers

Nobody’s saying banish the tools. The useful distinction is between thinking work and support work.

Before writing, AI shines. Sifting through research, structuring messy notes, finding patterns in data, summarizing what competitors have said. All of that speeds up preparation without touching your argument. During this phase the AI is a research assistant, and the ideas are still yours.

After writing, AI works as a reader. Bakker’s own method: don’t ask it to fix your draft, ask it questions about your draft. What questions would a skeptical reader have? What’s the single most important takeaway here? Where does the argument get shaky? The answers send you back into thinking mode, which is exactly where you want to be. Compare that with our guide to ChatGPT custom instructions, where the goal is making the tool respond the way you need rather than think for you.

The middle part, the actual writing, is where he draws the line. That’s the part that’s slow because it’s supposed to be slow.

A workflow that keeps you in charge

If you want to try this without going full purist, here’s the shape of it.

  1. Research with AI freely. Gather sources, compress notes, map the territory.
  2. Close the chat. Write the first draft yourself, even if it’s clumsy. Especially if it’s clumsy.
  3. Reopen the chat as a critic, not a co-author. Ask what’s unclear, what’s missing, what a reader would push back on.
  4. Decide what to change yourself. Take the feedback into your own edits.

Think of it as using AI to write around your draft instead of the draft itself. This mirrors the rule we keep coming back to in pieces like our guide to using AI at work safely: the tool assists, but the judgment and the accountability stay with you. It also matters more as detection gets easier. The AI job application doom loop showed what happens when everyone automates the same step; sameness gets punished, and the people who sound like themselves cut through.

The honest tradeoff

Let’s not pretend this is free. Writing your own drafts takes longer. Sometimes a generated first draft is fine, like routine meeting notes or a boilerplate update where the ideas were never the point. Bakker’s rule targets work where the thinking matters: strategy docs, essays, important emails, anything with your name and your judgment attached.

For that work, the math has flipped. Using AI to write it saves you an hour and quietly costs you the one thing the document was supposed to produce, which is a thought you actually own. The survey data suggests people sense this even when they keep using the tools. Sixty percent distrust their own output. Your readers probably do too.

So try the split for a week. AI for research, AI for critique, and the drafting keeps your hands on the keyboard. Worst case, you lose a little speed. Best case, the next thing you publish says something only you could have said.

You Might Also Like

Google AI voice features: talk to Gmail, Docs, and Keep
Starbucks killed its AI tool after 9 months (Here is why)
Notification highlights: the hidden Samsung AI time-saver
AI video search: find anything in your recordings (Clipto guide)
Claude Code cross-session messaging: stop copy-pasting between sessions
TAGGED:AI mistakesAI ProductivityAI writingWriting
Share
Previous Article Tobi Lutke, Shopify's chief executive, speaking at a public event AI slop is making your job harder, not easier
Next Article Android phone showing Google AI Edge Gallery running a local AI model offline Run a local LLM on your phone: 5 offline tasks worth trying
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

banner banner
Create an Amazing Newspaper
Discover thousands of options, easy to customize layouts, one-click to import demo and much more.
Learn More

Latest News

Nest Hub smart display in a living room showing visual answers from Gemini for Home
Gemini for Home update: visual answers on your Nest display
Tools
Mac laptop showing the ChatGPT desktop app with a computer activity timeline logged behind it
ChatGPT Computer History: what it saves and how to stop it
Tools
Claude Meetings interface with an AI participant drafting a plan during a video call
Claude Meetings: Anthropic’s AI joins your video calls
Productivity
Apple Watch on a wrist showing a Siri voice prompt overlay
Siri Recap: how to turn it on (and why you might wait)
Productivity

Recent Posts

  • Gemini for Home update: visual answers on your Nest display
  • ChatGPT Computer History: what it saves and how to stop it
  • Claude Meetings: Anthropic’s AI joins your video calls
  • Siri Recap: how to turn it on (and why you might wait)
  • Notion AI data breach: what leaked and what to do

Recent Comments

  1. Gemini for Home update: visual answers on your Nest display on Gemini automations on Android: 5 worth setting up today
  2. ChatGPT Computer History: what it saves and how to stop it on ChatGPT locked chats: how to set up the PIN lock
  3. Claude Meetings: Anthropic's AI joins your video calls on Claude Duet: Anthropic’s proactive AI agent explained
  4. Siri Recap: how to turn it on (and why you might wait) on iOS 27.2: five new iPhone features worth the update
  5. Notion AI data breach: what leaked and what to do on Files you should never upload to ChatGPT

You Might also Like

Notebook with handwritten test scores beside a laptop running an AI chatbot
Productivity

How to build a personal AI benchmark that fits your work

Editorial Team
Editorial Team
10 Min Read
iPhone showing a low battery warning while charging
Productivity

iOS 27 battery drain: the one setting to turn off

Editorial Team
Editorial Team
7 Min Read
ChatGPT panel open beside Chrome browser tabs during a comparison task
Tools

ChatGPT Chrome tabs: let AI read and work in your browser

Editorial Team
Editorial Team
11 Min Read
//

We influence 20 million users and is the number one business and technology news network on the planet

Quick Link

  • PRIVACY NOTICE
  • YOUR PRIVACY RIGHTS
  • INTEREST-BASE ADSNew
  • TERMS OF USE
  • OUR SITE MAP

Support

  • ADVERTISE
  • ONLINE BESTHot
  • CUSTOMER
  • SERVICES
  • SUBSCRIBE

Categories

  • Tools
© 2026 Logic and Layers. All Rights Reserved.